BACK TO NEWS & OPINION

Broward News & Opinion

16-BIT NEWS AND COMMENTARY FOR SOUTH FLORIDA

FLOODS, FLOODS AND MORE FLOODS. SOMEBODY PULL THE PLUG.

BY AARON NEVINS
11/22/2026
8-bit Super Mario-style scene of a plumber in a red P cap standing knee-deep in floodwater beside a maze of green pipes.
WORLD 1-2: THE WATER LEVEL. NO WARP PIPE OUT.

Another week, another flood.

Cars stranded, streets underwater and homeowners watching the water creep toward their front doors. Meanwhile, we're treated to another round of explanations about king tides, climate change and rising sea levels.

But there's something else we ought to be talking about.

Flap Gates

Over the past decade, cities across South Florida have installed hundreds of these devices on stormwater pipes to prevent tidal water from backing up into neighborhoods.

They're relatively cheap, mechanically simple and perfectly sound engineering. They do exactly what they're supposed to do, and that may be precisely the problem.

Anybody who's ever taken a bath understands how this works.

Put the plug in the drain, turn on the faucet and the bathtub fills up. Pull the plug and the water disappears.

That's essentially what we've built in neighborhoods across Broward County.

When the tide rises, the gates close to keep water from backing up through our storm drains. But when heavy rain falls while the gates are closed, that same system can prevent the rainwater from getting out.

The streets fill. The water rises. And everybody waits inside the bathtub.

Then the tide drops, the gates can reopen and suddenly the water starts disappearing.

It's like somebody pulled the plug.

The system isn't malfunctioning, elected officials insist. And they're not lying! It's doing exactly what it was designed to do.

In fact, back in 2017, Fort Lauderdale's Chief Resilience Officer Nancy Gassman told the BBC about one of Fort Lauderdale's earliest tidal valve installations. A king tide had flooded a street, but the water couldn't drain because the valve wouldn't open.

The streets remained flooded around the clock.

"We have had complaints that the valves aren't working. But no. The valves are working," Gassman said.

Nine years later, we've got 215 tidal valves, flooded neighborhoods and vacuum trucks trying to keep the water out of people's homes.

"As long as there is oceanic water pushing on the valve, it cannot open," Gassman told Local 10. But the gates don't know if the water is from the ocean or being pumped east to sea.

When a neighborhood's gates are closed and there aren't sufficient pumps to move the water, those residents are effectively at the back of the line. Their water must wait until conditions allow it to escape.

And every additional inch of rain means another inch of trouble.

This isn't some undiscovered engineering problem.

North Carolina State University specifically warns that flap gates can prevent stormwater from draining during high tides, allowing pipes to fill until flooding occurs.

More locally, Hollywood's engineers acknowledge in its stormwater master plan that backflow devices add resistance to drainage and often require larger pipes and additional storage to compensate.

In other words, you can't just install a valve and call it a day. You need a drainage system capable of handling the consequences.

We Traded Puddles for Swimming Pools

Back in 2016, Inside Climate News reported that Gassman, then an assistant public works director, discussed the drawbacks of installing permanent pumping systems.

They were expensive, required maintenance and generated greenhouse gas emissions.

Greenhouse gas emissions.

I wonder what the carbon footprint looks like on a fleet of vacuum trucks driving around Fort Lauderdale trying to empty the city's bathtubs.

Maybe we ought to spend a little more time listening to the stormwater engineers in Hollywood and a little less time listening to climate activists like Gassman worrying about the environmental credentials of pumping water out of people's neighborhoods.

And lest anybody think this is strictly a coastal problem, take a drive through Plantation.

Miles inland, the city has incorporated the same backflow prevention technology into its stormwater improvement plans.

Mayor Nick Sortal is still bragging the Zone 3 drainage project includes WaStop valves designed to prevent water from backing up into neighborhood drainage systems.

During this week's flooding, Plantation reported receiving an average of 12 inches of rain. Neighborhoods flooded, roads became impassable and officials scrambled to deploy 12 portable pumps.

The city's backflow valve plans deserve particular attention. We ought to know which valves have actually been installed, how they performed during the storm and whether they restricted drainage when neighborhoods needed it most.

The same scrutiny belongs in every Broward city using these devices.

Because a flood prevention system that depends on emergency equipment showing up after the streets flood isn't much of a prevention system.

It's a cleanup plan.

The Post-Amendment 3 Reality

Florida voters just approved Amendment 3, and local governments are going to have to take a serious look at their priorities.

Frankly, that's overdue.

For years, cities have found money for sustainability initiatives, resilience offices, consultants, studies and the staff needed to explain why everything is getting worse.

Meanwhile, the people who actually understand drainage engineering are left trying to make aging infrastructure work with whatever money elected officials are willing to provide.

Hollywood's engineers have already spelled out the problem. Backflow valves add resistance to drainage. Additional capacity costs money.

That's what City Hall needs to focus on.

In Fort Lauderdale, I'd start by eliminating the chief resilience officer position now occupied by Gassman, fire her, and return responsibility for flood protection to the engineers in Public Works.

We've had enough climate presentations and self flagellation. We need working drainage.

Broward legislators like Reps. Dan Daley and Mitch Rosenwald should ask the Joint Legislative Auditing Committee to order an independent audit of the money spent on flap gates and stormwater infrastructure across Broward County.

Let's find out what the engineers recommended, what elected officials actually funded and whether the millions we've spent have reduced flooding or simply changed when and how it happens.

If taxpayers paid for flood prevention but ended up with a fleet of vacuum trucks, somebody ought to follow the money.

And let's have independent engineers examine whether these valves are making catastrophic flooding worse. Before another city installs another round of backflow valves, its elected officials should demand the complete engineering picture.

We reduced the frequency of nuisance flooding while creating the possibility that heavy rain would become trapped behind those same valves.

Instead of a few inches of water in the street several times a year, we now risk feet of water when a major storm arrives at precisely the wrong time.

And with serious flooding seeming to arrive every year or two, I'm beginning to wonder whether we've made a terrible bargain.

The nuisance flooding during king tides was an inconvenience.

Catastrophic flooding every year or so is untenable.

© 2026 PAINTED DOG PRODUCTIONS

16-BIT NEWS AND COMMENTARY FOR THE DIGITAL AGE